After a record 132 million votes counted, American has crowned their eleventh Idol. And, as Vote For The Worst puts it, it keeps alive their streak in the form of the hashtag #wgwg5, or “white guy with guitar 5”; the fifth Idol winner in a row to be…well, just that. In any case, congratulations to Philip Phillips, who overcame his parents who obviously named him expecting him to go nowhere in life. But as for Jessica Sanchez, the 16-year old Filipina-Mexican with a booming voice, I hardly think this is the end of the road for her.
First of all, she’s gotten further than any Pilipino before her. We’ve all cheered for Camile, Jasmine, Ramiele, and Thia in the past. And while we may not hear from them all the time like we did during their runs on the show, I always see support from the Pilipino community when they have something in the works. Add that to the fact that she’s still only 16and you know her journey’s just beginning.
And let’s not forget that Jessica’s not necessarily missing out on anything by not placing first. Sure, it’s a great title you can carry for the rest of your career, but it doesn’t guarantee anything beyond that. Yes, Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood have gone on to huge things in the music business. But Taylor Hicks – not so much. David Cook is unsigned. And I still have to look up the fact that Lee DeWyze actually won his season. Add the fact that you basically get locked into a contract upon winning and have to play by Idol’s rules, and it’s not quite the greatest thing in the world.
Compare that to the myriad of stars Idol has churned out that weren’t Idol champs. Chris Daughtry was pretty much relieved that he didn’t win, and when his band took off it made a lot more sense. Season three was packed with talent – LaToya London and Diana DeGarmo had great success on Broadway, and of course Jennifer Hudson from that group has won a Grammy and an Osacar. Idol runner-up Katharine McPhee is currently starring on the hit TV show “Smash”.
Jessica Sanchez coming in second was a disappointment to many Pilipinos, but in the end it may be better for Jessica individually. As the final performance episode showed, her first single was something that didn’t play to her strengths or style. Following that, her first album would have been similar, and she would be contractually obligated to go through with it. Hopefully Jessica will continue the trend that winning isn’t everything.

